Steve Rich's Weather and Outdoors
Information about current weather and climate news and other related (or sometimes unrelated) topics
Wednesday, October 16, 2019
Friday, February 6, 2015
Thursday, March 6, 2014
An analysis of an isolated severe thunderstorm event with injuries in Summerville (and an illustration of why severe thunderstorm warnings should be taken seriously)…
Introduction
This analysis examines
an isolated severe thunderstorm event that occurred in the Summerville, SC,
area on July 28, 2008. High winds from the storm blew down a few trees and
large limbs, causing one serious injury in the Pineridge Trailer Park on the
northern side of town just inside Berkeley County.
Thunderstorm Basics
A thunderstorm can
develop only if sufficient moisture and instability are present. The developing
stage is marked by growing cumulus clouds, resulting from a rising column of
air called an updraft. The initial lift is provided by some method of forcing –
usually surface heating, or air moving over terrain or “boundaries” such as
fronts, sea breeze boundaries, or outflow boundaries from other thunderstorms.
In this area the most common factors in summer are surface heating and the sea
breeze. Outflow from other thunderstorms complicates things on many days and
can lead to more intense storms. In any case, the cumulus grows into a
“towering” cumulus as the updraft continues to develop. Little if any rain is
likely during this stage, but lightning is possible. The developing stage lasts
on the order of 10 to 30 minutes.
The thunderstorm enters the mature stage when the updraft continues to feed the storm.
Latent heat is released to the environment as the moisture in the rising air
condenses, providing further buoyancy. Precipitation begins to fall out of the
storm, and a downdraft (a column of air pushing downward) begins. When the
downdraft’s rain-cooled air spreads out along the ground it forms a “gust
front," which is simply an outflow characterized by gusty winds. Usually these wind
gusts are less than 40 mph. If conditions are right for a more intense storm
than usual to form, the mature stage is the most likely time for hail, heavy
rain, lightning strikes, strong winds, and (only if conditions are right) tornadoes
to occur.
Eventually, a large amount of precipitation (some water, some
ice – the freezing level here was 15,000 feet on July 28, 2008) -- is produced and
the updraft is overcome (“loaded”) by a downdraft, beginning the dissipating stage. If enough dry air is present in “middle”
levels (say, 6 to 15 thousand feet), the descending air is further cooled
through evaporation of some of the rain and hail, and the potential for
stronger downdrafts increases because the air becomes even cooler and heavier. At the ground, the gust front moves out a
significant distance from the storm and cuts off the warm moist air that was
feeding the thunderstorm. Rainfall decreases in intensity. The storm then
usually falls apart fairly quickly, but its outflow may leave boundaries in
place for new storms to form.
The storm over the
Charleston Tri-County area on the afternoon of July 28, 2008, was what is
called an intense single cell thunderstorm. Most single cell storms do not
become severe. However, it is possible for one to produce a brief severe
weather event. When this happens, it is called a “pulse” type severe storm.
Their updrafts and downdrafts are stronger, and typically produce hail that may
barely reach severe limits and/or brief microbursts (a strong downdraft of air
that hits the ground and then spreads out).
Brief heavy rainfall and occasionally a weak tornado are possible.
Though pulse severe storms tend to form in more unstable environments than
non-severe single cell storms, they are usually more poorly organized and occur at
seemingly random times and locations, making it impossible to forecast exactly
where they will form.
Synopsis
for July 28, 2008
Below is the surface
map for July 29, 2008 at 18Z (GMT) – or 2:00 pm EDT (all times are EDT unless
otherwise noted). It shows a typical summer pattern in place over the eastern
part of the country. The remains of a weak cold front that aided in earlier
thunderstorm development overnight are dissipating over eastern North Carolina.
Atlantic high pressure was centered well offshore, with a moist
and potentially unstable air mass in place over the southeastern states,
including coastal South Carolina. A weak surface trough of low pressure was in
place over inland areas. The general weather
conditions and synoptic pattern were typical for the area for late July.
Temperatures and dew points had been running near to slightly above normal for
the previous few days. Daytime highs across the area were generally in the
middle 90s on July 28, after morning lows in the low to mid 70s. No rain was
recorded at Summerville (the “co-op” station 4 miles west of town is part of
NWS’s cooperative observer network). A trace of rain was recorded at the
Charleston NWS Forecast Office at the airport.
The morning upper air (balloon) sounding data
indicated a good amount of potential instability. Most of the severe
weather-related indices (computed from the actual sounding) indicated values
not much out of the ordinary for the area for July, but suggested sufficient
instability for a few strong storms to develop in the afternoon. The NWS at
Charleston indicated in its late morning and early afternoon Area Forecast
Discussion (AFD) that the sounding showed a strong low-level “capping
inversion” (a stable layer in the lowest few thousand feet) which would likely
inhibit thunderstorm development until at least the early or middle part of the
afternoon…when surface heating could “break” the cap.
The sea breeze was also expected to assist in
the thunderstorm development once the capping inversion was broken sometime
after noon. The sea breeze was not well defined or particularly strong on this
day and was actually rather diffuse, unlike what we see on many days. A general
southwesterly flow was already in place over the area, and the sea breeze
resulted in little noticeable change while moving slowly inland except for a
gradual shift of wind from the southwest to due south. By the time the sea
breeze had penetrated as far inland as Summerville, some convection had already
started to form inland, and outflow boundaries from a few storms were already
interacting with the sea breeze, limiting any further effect it may have had.
The sea breeze was never as highly visible on the radar this day as it often
is, though some of the outflow boundaries were quite distinct.
The Charleston NWS pointed out in the early
afternoon AFD that computer-generated numerical model forecast soundings
were showing quite a bit of drier air at mid and upper levels, which was
expected to “mix down” during the day. Therefore, they were expecting the
potential for a “few strong storms given the mid-level dry air and robust
potential instability.” The public zone forecast called for only a 20
percent chance of thunderstorms for the area, which ended up being a good
forecast for the Tri-County area, since most places did not receive rain.
Here is an excerpt from the AFD issued on the
28th at 1:43 pm (a repeat of the wording from the AFD issued at
10:49 am):
.NEAR TERM /UNTIL 6 PM THIS EVENING/...
MORNING SOUNDING SHOWS A STRONG 5 DEGREE CAP IN PLACE AND MID-
LEVELS ARE QUITE WARM WITH 700-500 MB LAPSE RATES BELOW 5C. THIS
IS THE RESULT OF THE 700 MB RIDGE AXIS SHIFTING EAST WITH MOST
OF
THE SHORTWAVE ENERGY BEING DEFLECTED TO THE NE OF THE AREA. IN
THE
LOWER LEVELS...A VERY WARM AND MOIST AIRMASS IS IN PLACE WITH
DEWPOINTS EXPECTED TO SURGE ALONG THE COAST WITH THE SEABREEZE.
INLAND QUITE A BIT OF DRIER AIR IS SHOWING UP IN MODEL SOUNDINGS
AND ON WATER VAPOR IMAGERY WHICH COULD PARTIALLY MIX DOWN DURING
THE DAY. MODIFIED 12Z CHS SOUNDING RESULTS IN CAPE VALUES IN
EXCESS OF 3500 WITH ABOUT 10 KT OF 0-4 KM SHEAR...INDICATING
MULTICELLS WILL AGAIN BE POSSIBLE. HOWEVER...THE LACK OF A CU
FIELD THUS FAR AND CONVECTIVE TEMPS IN THE LOWER 90S SHOWS THAT
IT
WILL PROBABLY BE UNTIL THE SEABREEZE BEGINS TO PUSH INLAND
BEFORE
ANY CONVECTION CAN FIRE. THE BEST COVERAGE EXPECTED IN SOUTHEAST
GEORGIA DUE TO THE HIGHER LOW-LEVEL DEWPOINTS AND LOWER
CONVECTIVE
TEMPS. WILL MAINTAIN CHANCE TO SLIGHT CHANCE POPS THIS
AFTERNOON.
WE MAY SEE A FEW STRONG STORMS GIVEN THE MID-LEVEL DRY AIR AND
ROBUST POTENTIAL INSTABILITY. HEAVY RAIN IS ALSO A THREAT.
INCREASING THICKNESSES WITH THE UPPER RIDGING AND MOSTLY SUNNY
SKIES WILL RESULT IN A WARM DAY ACROSS THE AREA. HIGHS IN THE
MID
90S EXPECTED INLAND WITH LOWER TO MIDDLE 90S CLOSER TO THE COAST.
DEWPOINTS COULD SURGE INTO THE UPPER 70S WITH THE SEABREEZE
AGAIN
WHICH WILL PROBABLY PUSH HEAT INDICES IN A THIN STRIPE ALONG THE
SC COAST ABOVE 105 FOR 1 TO 2 HOURS LATE IN THE AFTERNOON. HEAT ADVISORY LOOKS GOOD.
The figure below shows
the Day 1 Convective Outlook (AC) graphic issued by the NWS Storm Prediction
Center (SPC). Other areas in the country were considered to have a more
significant risk of severe storms on July 28, especially parts of the Dakotas.
The Carolinas were in the “general thunderstorm” area only…and were mentioned
in the discussion part of the AC issued at 740 am on the 28th:
...DEEP SOUTH INTO THE
CAROLINAS...
VERY MOIST LOW-LEVEL AIRMASS WILL CONTRIBUTE
TO MODERATE
DESTABILIZATION ACROSS THIS REGION...AND THE
SUBSEQUENT DEVELOPMENT
OF SCATTERED SHOWERS AND THUNDERSTORMS
DURING THE AFTERNOON.
GENERALLY WEAK FLOW ALOFT SHOULD LIMIT
OVERALL POTENTIAL FOR
ORGANIZATION...ALTHOUGH A FEW
STRONGER/PULSE-TYPE STORMS MAY PRODUCE
LOCALLY GUSTY WINDS AND/OR HAIL NEAR OR
BRIEFLY EXCEEDING SEVERE
LEVELS.
Even when conditions or forecasts for a specific area do not meet SPC’s criteria for issuance of a severe thunderstorm or tornado watch, those areas still may be included in a “slight risk” risk area in the AC. Otherwise, expected or developing conditions which may be potentially significant may be mentioned in SPC-issued “mesoscale discussions” (MCD). Regardless of whether any SPC products mention a specific area, NWS policy is for the local forecast offices (WFOs) to handle isolated occurrences in forecasts, statements and warnings as necessary. Though the Tri-County area was not singled out as being subject to any kind of enhanced risk, it is understood by NWS personnel, and by a sizable portion of the general public, that on the majority of days in the summer in this area, isolated strong storms are possible and a warning or two may be required. A watch is neither required nor desirable in these marginal cases.
Evolution of the event
Widely scattered thunderstorms developed in the middle and late afternoon across the CHS county warning area (CWA), which comprises 20 counties in South Carolina and Georgia, and extends from the South Santee River (near Georgetown) to the Altamaha River in Georgia (near Brunswick). Thunderstorm coverage was expected to be greater in Georgia than in southern South Carolina, which proved to be the case. A few warnings were issued across the CWA during the afternoon of July 28. In South Carolina, isolated damaging wind events were reported in Hampton and Dorchester counties.
The storm that produced damage near downtown Summerville (which was actually in Dorchester County) and in southeastern Berkeley County in the Pineridge Trailer Park on North Main Street in Summerville, began developing before 3 pm. Around 3 pm, the storm was centered 10 or 12 miles north of Summerville. It drifted slowly toward the southeast during the next hour and intensified. By 4:15 pm, the most intense part of the storm according to radar was about 2 miles to the east northeast of the trailer park.
The Charleston National Weather Service issued a severe thunderstorm warning which was effective from 4:17 pm until 5:15 pm, warning of the possibility of wind gusts exceeding 60 mph. The warning verified with a report of wind damage (tree down across road) near downtown Summerville, a few miles southwest of Pineridge. The official time of that event was logged as 4:35 pm, based on a report from the public.
Radar data also indicated that the storm top (“echo top”) was highest between 3:53 pm and 4:14 pm. Here are two radar images of the storm cell, showing the base reflectivity and the "echo tops" at that time. The reflectivity is an indication of the intensity of the storm, and can help meteorologists determine the location of the potential downdraft core.
The public reported a tree down across the road…near or just east of the Summerville downtown area…which was reported to the NWS. It was judged to be evidence of 50 knot (58 mph) wind gusts or higher and therefore verified the NWS warning. The event is recorded in the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) publication “Storm Data.” It is available from NOAA’s National Climatic Data Center in Asheville, NC, and from the NWS Storm Prediction Center in Norman, OK. The official reported time of the event (4:35 pm EDT) fits the radar data quite well. Based on this fact and on the available radar data in general, it is consistent with the timing of the event at Pineridge. Any strong downburst winds should have occurred there before reaching downtown Summerville, since Pineridge was closer to the core of the storm.
Since wind measuring equipment doesn’t exist at the vast majority of locations where damage occurs, professional judgment is exercised by NWS meteorologists in determining whether the evidence is sufficient to presume winds at the 50 knot threshold (or higher), which, by definition, is considered a “severe thunderstorm.”
The NWS guideline for determining whether 50+ knot winds have occurred -- whether to train storm spotters, to classify weather events, or to measure “ground truth” data while managing warning services during an ongoing severe weather event -- is the following: Large limbs break; shallow rooted trees pushed over. Semi-trucks overturned. More significant damage to old/weak structures. Shingles, awnings removed from houses; damage to chimneys and antennas. Dead branches and trees that are obviously weak or diseased are not considered sufficient evidence.
In an effort to obtain critical information, NOAA and NWS established what is known as the Skywarn Program in the 1970s, in partnership with FEMA and other organizations. The backbone of the program is the training and effective use of volunteers as storm spotters. There are now about 300,000 trained storm spotters, including police and fire personnel, dispatchers, EMS workers, public utility workers and many other concerned private citizens. Their feedback provides important “ground truth” and verification information to complement radar and other resources in accurately assessing what is occurring on a real-time basis, and in knowing what actually did occur. This is a critical part of efforts to continually improve and fine tune warning techniques.
The role of spotters is as critical as ever, even in the age of Doppler radar and other advanced technology. Information about Skywarn can be found here, which is from the Charleston NWS Forecast Office web page. Official Skywarn spotters are trained to recognize and report severe weather – and to estimate wind speeds, according to the guidelines listed in the Weather Spotter Quick Reference Guide.
The “base velocity” radar product was examined but was of little help. The WSR-88D Doppler radar used for Charleston’s area of responsibility is located near the rural town of Grays in Jasper County, about 50 miles southwest of downtown Summerville. At the radar’s lowest elevation angle (0.5 degree), the center of the radar beam is “looking” at what is happening about 4,000 feet above the ground. It typically does not detect downbursts at that range, since the cold air layer spreading out from the downdraft is usually much shallower than 4,000 feet. The radar “overshoots” anything happening below the beam. There was some indication of an outflow from the thunderstorm toward the radar, but again, only at 4,000 feet or higher. Most of the radar’s velocity data for the area around Summerville/Goose Creek were “range-folded” (a radar term meaning ambiguous). The radar velocity product is therefore not relied upon by meteorologists as a critical decision-making tool for warnings of strong straight-line winds, because of its inability to measure winds close to the ground (except in areas much closer to the radar site).
An interesting note was that on radar there was a very large precipitation gradient over the particular area in question. The “one-hour precipitation” display indicated that something on the order of ¼ inch of rain likely fell near Pineridge, while immediately southwest of there (as close as I-26), less than a tenth of an inch fell. Within 2 miles to the northeast, over an inch may have fallen. The radar data are only estimates, but show a sharp contrast in rainfall amounts across a short distance. Pineridge was on the edge of the storm. The spot near downtown Summerville where the tree was blown down appeared to have received less than 1/10 inch of rain.
Conclusion
High winds from the downdraft core of the thunderstorm for which the NWS warning was issued likely caused a very large limb in a trailer park to break and fall onto a mobile home, resulting in a serious and permanent injury to a resident. It is likely that isolated wind gusts of 50 knots (58 mph) or higher occurred in the area between the thunderstorm’s center (2 miles east northeast of the trailer park) to approximately the downtown part of Summerville. Radar data suggest that the strongest outflow winds pushed west-southwest through this area approximately between 4:20 and 4:35 pm. The timing of the known events correlates well with the radar data.
Primary data sources for this analysis included:
Radar Data: http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/radar/radarresources.html (NCDC Radar Resources)
Archived warnings and warning polygons: http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/kml/ (Virtual Globe Archived Severe Weather Warnings)
Storm Event Data Base: http://www4.ncdc.noaa.gov/cgi-win/wwcgi.dll?wwEvent~Storms (NCDC)
NWS text products: (forecasts, warnings, forecast discussions, mesoscale discussions, convective outlooks, statements, etc.): http://has.ncdc.noaa.gov/pls/plhas/has.dsselect (NCDC’s HDSS Access System) and www.spc.noaa.gov (Storm Prediction Center, Norman, OK)
Some interesting observations about dangerous heat index anomalies along parts of southeastern U.S. coast
In excessive heat regimes during summer
in the southeastern U.S. ,
depending on the synoptic-scale pattern, sea breeze penetration is often notably
slower than usual, with arrival - at least a few miles inland - occurring much
later in the day than on the majority of summer days. There doesn't necessarily
have to be a strong offshore flow for this to occur. Real-time data have
revealed significant spikes in heat index values in the first 1 to 2
hours following the initial arrival of the sea breeze discontinuity. With a
slowly-penetrating sea breeze transition zone, the dew point may
rise abruptly into the upper 70s or lower 80s with sea breeze arrival,
while the temperature falls more gradually. Short-term spikes in heat
index values to dangerous levels of 115 degrees or higher occur at
times, until the marine layer becomes well established and the temperature
drops further.
NWS Cooperative station
Edisto Island Middleton was commissioned in January 2004, and is located about 5 miles from the immediate coast. The cooperative
observer ("Co-op") site has been equipped with a variety of instrumentation. The data for this write-up was obtained from a Davis
“Vantage Pro 2” weather station that continuously monitors temperature, dew
point, wind, pressure, precipitation and other variables, and computes a “heat
index” (or apparent temperature) as well. Customarily, observations are logged
and archived at 30-minute intervals, but can be set to archive as frequently as
every minute. The Davis ’s inside receiving unit records and
displays maximum daily values of the measured elements and the derived indices.
Observations during the past five
summers (2004 through 2008) suggest the existence of an occasionally occurring mesoscale phenomenon,
previously neither well-recognized nor appreciated, which is associated with
periods of well above-normal summer temperatures (“heat waves” or “hot spells”).
This effect may be most pronounced in a relatively narrow “sub-zone” - oriented
along and seaward of the sea breeze front - on the order of only a few miles
wide embedded within the broader “coastal zone” along the southeastern U.S. coast.
For purposes of this
discussion, the “coastal zone” will refer to the strip along the coast that is directly
impacted by the sea breeze on most days in summer. Average distance of sea
breeze penetration along the Southeast coast varies with the orientation and
geography of the coast line. During unusually hot periods, the sea breeze seems
to become more “subdued” and less dramatic, both in effect and the distance it
is able to penetrate inland. On some days, it appears to start developing later
than normal, and moves inland very slowly. This may allow temperatures only a
few miles from the coast to climb nearly as high, or perhaps as high, as temperatures
much further inland. The sea breeze typically arrives at Middleton between noon and 2 p.m. during the summer. During periods of excessive
heat, what is often observed and revealed in the observations at
the Middleton Co-op site 5 miles inland is a late-arriving sea breeze (4 or 5 p.m.,
near the time the maximum temperature would occur with no sea breeze), accompanied
by a sudden significant increase in dew point temperature. For a period ranging
from 30 minutes to an hour or more, the dew point temperature increases more
rapidly than the air temperature drops.
This results in some anomalously high (but short-lived) heat index
values.
Along the lower coast of South Carolina , the
average daily sea breeze penetration is 30 miles or more, greater than in most
other areas for two main reasons. First, in summer, the dominant synoptic-scale
feature affecting the area is the Bermuda High, resulting in a prevailing southwesterly
low-level synoptic-scale flow, generally parallel to the SC coast. On a typical day, therefore, early in the process of
daily sea breeze formation (i.e., shortly after the temperature differentials
that force the marine layer inland start to become pronounced) areas near the
beach may start to feel a breeze off the water as the surface southwesterly
flow gradually backs to the south or southeast. The sea breeze often starts at
the immediate coast well before noon
on days when the prevailing winds are southwest, or have only a light offshore
component. Geographically, the lower South Carolina coast is also characterized
by numerous barrier islands (part of the “Sea Islands” that extend roughly from
just north of Charleston, SC to near Jacksonville, FL), and by extensive areas
of low-elevation coastal marshlands and waterways. This allows for the sea
breeze to progress inland relatively unimpeded (compared to heavily forested
areas that would offer a little more resistance).
Further south along the Georgia and
northern Florida
coasts, the coast line runs generally north-south (and the marshlands don’t
extend as far inland). The prevailing southwest flow in summer therefore has a greater
offshore component there, so the developing sea breeze is opposed or “held off”
longer in these areas on a typical day. The offshore component of the
prevailing flow also helps limit the distance the sea breeze moves inland
during the day. The average daily penetration is closer to 20 to 25 miles along
much of the Georgia
coast and the east coast of Florida .
(It’s also less on the upper South Carolina
coast, and into lower North Carolina ,
than on the lower SC coast.)
During periods when strong
high pressure settles over the region, mostly clear (but often hazy) skies and
well-above normal temperatures may persist over the Southeast for several days
or longer (or, infrequently, for weeks with occasional short breaks). The hot
air mass, and the high percentage of sunshine, gradually warm the coastal
waters. Surface water temperatures may eventually climb into the middle or even
upper 80s off the southern South
Carolina coast.
During
heat waves, with high pressure centered over the Southeast, the onset of the
sea breeze becomes typically later, as the land/sea temperature and pressure
differentials seem less effective in developing a distinct sea breeze, or at
least the process is retarded. When the high pressure system is situated so
that the synoptic-scale low-level flow is more northwesterly (perpendicular to
the coast), the sea breeze can be significantly delayed, and if the offshore
component is higher than 10 mph, Middleton (5 miles inland) may not feel the
sea breeze until after 6 p.m.
With
the very warm coastal surface water temperatures, early morning minimum air
temperatures over the near-shore waters likely remain in the lower 80s to even
mid 80s (unfortunately, observational data is sparse here). Minimum readings a
few miles inland will typically be in the 75 to 80 degree range. The
anomalously warm sea surface temperatures may allow air temperatures even at
the beach to stay at or slightly above 90 degrees until well after sea breeze
onset. On such days, the sea breeze brings little relief even at the immediate
coast.
Late
in the day, however, the sea breeze may be reinforced by slightly cooler air in
the marine layer from further offshore, where the deeper waters are slower to
warm than the quite shallow waters closer to shore (the ocean floor slopes very
gradually off this part of the coast). Once the sea breeze finally does fully
develop, the pressure gradient along the coast may force the sea breeze to blow
with stronger force than usual late in the afternoon when air temperature
differences between the coast and the interior become greatest.
The observed spikes in heat
index values seem to be most noticeable within a zone probably only a few miles
wide, where air with very high dew points (80 degrees or higher) in the marine
layer only a short distance behind the sea breeze “front” meets the hotter,
somewhat drier air over the interior. The sea breeze front is not a true discontinuity,
but rather a narrow zone of transition. In these scenarios it appears to be
more diffuse than is normally the case. Mixing of the high dew point marine layer
with the hotter, drier air inland is occurring in this narrow zone which is
progressing slowly inland and becoming gradually more diffuse. The highest heat
index values appear to occur between a few and perhaps 10 to 15 miles from the
coast. The effect seems less pronounced as far inland as the Charleston airport (where the official Charleston readings are
taken). Typically, the temperature 20 to 25 miles inland has started to drop by
the time the later-than-normal sea breeze arrival occurs there (perhaps after 7
p.m.), and the extremely high dew points that were able to make it several
miles inland have “mixed out” somewhat with the “drier” air over the interior by
that time.
The conclusion? A heat index value of 115 degrees or
higher (for any period of time) meets the NWS criteria for an excessive heat
warning. Yet, there is a paucity of readily available observational data in the
area, and the phenomenon may occur without ever being noticed or detected.
There are potentially dangerous consequences for people who stay outdoors in
these conditions, and especially if they are engaging in any strenuous
activity. There are usually large numbers of people at the beach or on the Sea Islands during such weather conditions. During
excessive heat regimes, a later-than-usual arriving sea breeze may bring a
temporary increase in the apparent temperature, or at the very least may
maintain heat index values, for a couple of hours or longer, near the same
levels as prior to sea breeze arrival.
Wednesday, March 5, 2014
Thursday, February 6, 2014
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)